Tag Archives: BRCA gene

Myriad and the Supreme Court: A Battle of Ownership in the Field of Genetic Testing

Posted on by
Supreme Court BRCA gene patent

The unanimous decision by the Supreme Court Justices to strike down patent claims by Myriad Genetics on the BRCA gene is a milestone that will greatly shape the future of the genetic testing industry and, in fact, accelerate progress toward the use of whole-genome sequencing for patients well beyond breast cancer.

Recently the Supreme Court struck down patent claims by Myriad Genetics on the BRCA gene. The Court ruled that while synthetically produced DNA may be patentable, isolated genomic DNA (gDNA), discovered in nature and separated from its environment in the cell, is not patent-eligible.

The unanimous decision by the Supreme Court Justices has significant implications for patients, physicians, and the health care and life sciences industries. In many ways, this is a milestone that will greatly shape the future of the genetic testing industry and, in fact, accelerate progress toward the use of whole-genome sequencing for patients well beyond breast cancer.

Within a day of the Court’s verdict, 10 companies announced their intention to compete with Myriad—and more are sure to follow, as BRCA has proven to be a very relevant gene for assessing risk levels, disease targets, and potential treatments.

While this industry flurry illustrates the potentially significant commercial opportunity here, the greater implication is that the landscape is beginning to shift toward sequence analysis on a genome-wide basis rather than on individual gene testing.

Because fundamentally, the gene-by-gene approach to genetic testing that would be necessary if individual companies had patents on certain genetic tests is un-economical and wasteful, compared with the scope of knowledge and insights to be gained from a whole-genome sequencing analysis. As evidenced by Myriad’s recent announcements to abandon individual BRCA testing by 2014, it seems they also acknowledge this trend.

Ultimately, then, the future of competition in genetic testing will be driven by the ever-improving tools for sequencing, managing genomic data, and manipulating large data sets—and not simply by patents on DNA sequences discovered in nature.

Share on Tumblr
0
email

Angelina Jolie: Genetic Testing in the Mainstream Spotlight

Posted on by

angelina jolie genetic testing decision

Angelina Jolie is perhaps the first highly visible public figure to “endorse” the idea of gene screening and make a very personal, radical medical decision as a result.

The May 14 New York Times featured an op-ed from recognized actress Angelina Jolie, entitled “My Medical Choice.” The piece recapped why she had her genes sequenced, and why she made the decision to undergo prophylactic bilateral mastectomy upon finding that she carried a very high-risk mutation in her BRCA gene. That mutation gave her a high likelihood of getting the same type of cancer that killed her mother.

Ms. Jolie is perhaps the first highly visible public figure to “endorse” the idea of gene screening and make a very personal, radical medical decision as a result. Her decision is a poignant example of the recent trend toward consumer-driven healthcare, wherein consumers take on a partnership role with their doctor in making major decisions, informed by science, which will greatly impact their future.

This trend will only accelerate as more technologies like whole genome sequencing are developed to aid in the decision-making process. As consumers gain increased access to medical information, they are more proactively seeking solutions that work for their personal circumstances.

The challenge for all of us in the health care industry is to embrace this empowered patient—and to work with them to ensure that they are part of making the best decision for their individual situation.  Embracing patient empowerment implies new attitudes for physicians and health care providers, as well as new economic considerations for hospitals, insurance companies, and service providers.

It should be noted that Jolie was among the minority of the population who can currently afford to seek the data, information, and counsel she needed to help her make her medical choices based on her established family risks.

However, as technology evolves and expanded uses for genetic testing helps to drive industry-wide economies of scale, these types of tests will become more broadly available to everyone. Ultimately, these tests and the medical care that they enable will become a routine part of mainstream care for all.